Share on Pinterest
Is this mattress worth the money?

We include products we think are useful for our readers. If you buy through links on this page, we may earn a small commission. Here’s our process.

Having the right mattress can drastically improve your quality of sleep. Between support, firmness, and temperature, there are several factors that affect how well you snooze on a mattress.

Experts recommend getting a new mattress every 6 to 8 years, or as close to it as possible. Most mattresses last about that long. However, a mattress that’s very high quality could give you a good night’s sleep for even longer.

Here, we’re reviewing the Serta Perfect Sleeper mattress — a well known mattress that gets overwhelmingly positive reviews. We’ll break down its pros and cons, who it’s a good choice for, and how it stacks up against competitors.

The 17-inch high Serta Perfect Sleeper mattress provides pressure-relieving comfort and support while also keeping the temperature balanced as you sleep. The mattress is made with gel memory foam that contours to your body.

It also includes a coil system that reduces motion transfer so you won’t wake up a sleeping partner if you move. An additional foam encasement technology ensures that you won’t accidentally roll off the side.

The mattress was recently updated and now provides over 40 percent better pressure relief than the previous Perfect Sleeper, aiming to alleviate aches and pains caused by pressure points.

Serta offers a 120-day, in-home free trial, free shipping and delivery, and a 10-year limited warranty. The Perfect Sleeper is designed and built in the United States.

Pros

  • available in multiple comfort levels
  • keeps the temperature balanced as you sleep
  • gel memory foam contours to your body to relieve pressure points
  • minimizes motion transfer and edge roll-off

Cons

  • recently recalled as a fire hazard
  • comes as-is and is difficult to maneuver into the bedroom

Since the Perfect Sleeper mattress comes in six different versions, it’s very versatile, appealing to all kinds of sleepers. Whether you sleep on your back, side, or stomach, you’ll be able to find a version of the mattress that works for you.

We specifically recommend this mattress for back and stomach sleepers. And if you sleep hot, the Perfect Sleeper is a great fit — this mattress works to keep your sleeping temperature balanced. It’s also worth noting that although the Perfect Sleeper is made with gel memory foam, it has more of an innerspring feel than memory foam.

This mattress comes in multiple thicknesses and sizes. The prices below are based on the cost of a queen-size mattress:

  • Renewed Night ($1,199). This version contains one layer of memory foam and is best for the stomach sleeper who likes pressure relief.
  • Renewed Night Firm ($1,199). This version contains one layer of memory foam and a pillow top, and is best for the sleeper in a bigger body who likes extra comfort.
  • Renewed Sleep ($1,399). This version contains two layers of memory foam and is best for the sleeper who likes additional comfort and softness.
  • Renewed Sleep Firm ($1,499). This version contains two layers of memory foam and a pillow top, and is best for the side sleeper who likes a contouring feel.
  • Luminous Sleep ($1,699). This version contains three layers of memory foam and is best for the average-size back or side sleeper who likes a plush feel for extra restorative sleep.
  • Luminous Sleep Firm ($1,899). This version contains three layers of memory foam and a pillow top, and is best for the sleeper who likes a more luxurious feel.

Overall, the Serta Perfect Sleeper gets good reviews online. Consumers say the mattress has a wonderful balance of firmness and support. They stay cool while sleeping, and the mattress is durable, making it a great investment.

According to most customers, the main drawback is that the mattress is delivered in its full shape, making it difficult to maneuver into the bedroom.

The Serta brand has been around for a while. The first Perfect Sleeper mattress was launched in 1931, 2 years before the Serta brand name was introduced. Despite their experience in the industry, however, Serta gets relatively low ratings online.

The brand has 3 out of 5 stars on Trustpilot, with reviews citing bad experiences with warranties and returns. Serta is not accredited by the Better Business Bureau and has an F on the site, with 40 complaints closed in just the last 12 months.

In early 2022, Serta recalled about 800 of their Perfect Sleeper mattresses that were manufactured in summer 2021. The mattresses posed a fire hazard because they did not meet the mandatory federal flammability standard for mattresses.

Consumers who had been using the mattresses received a replacement free of charge. No incidents or injuries were reported in association with the recall.

Serta Perfect Sleeper vs. Tuft & Needle Mint mattress

The Tuft & Needle Mint mattress is an all-foam mattress with good pressure relief, edge support, and temperature control — all similar features to the Perfect Sleeper. What’s different? The Mint comes compressed in a box and feels softer, with a foam feel.

Serta Perfect Sleeper vs. Zinus Green Tea mattress

The Zinus Green Tea mattress is a memory foam mattress that’s very soft and comfortable. If you prefer firmer beds, the Perfect Sleeper is a great choice for you.

Other things to note about the Green Tea: It sleeps hotter than most mattresses, but has excellent motion transfer. It’s also far more affordable than most bed-in-a-box options. Prices start at as low as $125.

Serta Perfect Sleeper vs. Nectar mattress

If you like mattresses with a memory foam feel, the Nectar is a good choice for you. With a 365-night trial period and a forever warranty (compared with Serta’s 120-day trial and 10-year limited warranty), this all-foam mattress comfortably contours to your body. However, its edge support and temperature control are not up to par with the Perfect Sleeper.

You can purchase a Serta Perfect Sleeper mattress on the Serta website or from a variety of other retailers, including:

  • Amazon
  • Bed Bath & Beyond
  • Big Lots
  • Macy’s
  • Mattress Firm
  • Target
  • Walmart
  • Wayfair

Which Serta Perfect Sleeper is the best?

The Serta Perfect Sleeper comes in six different versions, and each one is constructed with slightly different materials. You might prefer one version over another, depending on the size of your body and your sleeping position.

However, all mattresses are high quality choices that will provide you with a good night’s sleep.

How long does a Serta Perfect Sleeper last?

According to online reviews, the Serta Perfect Sleeper will likely last for 8 to 10 years. The mattress comes with a 10-year limited warranty.

Is the Serta Perfect Sleeper a firm mattress?

The firmness of the Perfect Sleeper depends on which of the six versions you purchase. Overall, though, the mattress is fairly firm. Although the mattress is made with gel memory foam, it has more of an innerspring feel.

The Serta Perfect Sleeper is a well known mattress for good reason. With contouring memory foam, temperature control, and excellent edge support, shoppers can choose from six total options that come in varying firmness levels.

Be aware that the mattress has been recalled as a fire hazard. However, overall, the Perfect Sleeper is a great fit to help you get a good night’s sleep.

Hailey Hudson is a full-time freelance writer and content marketer based out of Atlanta, Georgia. She focuses in the health, marketing, and education industries. Clients include Livestrong, Runner’s World, Dell, and others. Hailey is also a novelist and a musician.